- Profound is a strong enterprise product — most teams looking elsewhere are reacting to engine gating on its self-serve tiers, enterprise pricing on the full platform, or a wish for auditable methodology.
- The alternatives split cleanly: self-serve trackers (Peec, Otterly, AthenaHQ, MentionBeat), suite add-ons (Semrush, Ahrefs) and one enterprise like-for-like (Scrunch).
- Published entry prices run $29 to $398/month as of August 2026; Scrunch, like Profound's full platform, is sales-led.
- Before paying anyone, get a free read — a free tier or checker tells you whether you have a problem worth tracking.
First, the disclosure: MentionBeat (that's us) is one of the seven tools below. To keep this useful anyway, every claim about every tool — ours included — points at public pages checked in August 2026, and each entry ends with a plain "choose this if" you can disagree with.
Second, fairness to the incumbent: Profound earned its position. It covers eight platforms with up to nine on Enterprise, sells genuine demand-side data (prompt volumes), watches AI crawlers hit your site, and carries the SOC 2/SSO checklist enterprise procurement wants.1,2 If that's what you need, read our head-to-head MentionBeat vs Profound — this page is for everyone who got to the pricing conversation and wanted other options.
Why teams go looking
Three reasons come up again and again:
- Engine gating. As of August 2026, Profound's Starter ($99/month billed yearly) tracks ChatGPT only with 50 prompts, and Growth ($399/month billed yearly) tracks three engines with 100 prompts. The nine-engine platform is enterprise-priced via sales.1 Teams that need Claude and Gemini and AI Overviews on a mid-size budget hit that wall early.
- Fit. Dedicated Slack support and SSO/SAML are exactly right for a Fortune-1000 rollout — and a cost you carry without using if you're a 12-person team.
- Auditability. Some buyers want the measurement method — sampling, repetition, statistical treatment — published before they pay. That's a category-wide gap, not a Profound-specific one; hold every vendor on this page to it.
The alternatives at a glance
| Alternative | Starting price (public, Aug 2026) | Engine coverage | Choose it if |
|---|---|---|---|
| Peec AI | €85/mo3 | Pick 3 of 6 models per self-serve plan; up to 11 on Enterprise | You want focused, self-serve tracking with strong European roots |
| Otterly.AI | $29/mo4 | 4 base surfaces; Gemini, Claude, AI Mode as add-ons | Budget is the constraint and daily cadence matters |
| Scrunch AI | Not published — sales-led5 | ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude, Gemini, Copilot | You want enterprise like-for-like plus site optimization for agents |
| Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit | $99/mo per domain, billed annually6 | ChatGPT, Google AI, Gemini, Perplexity | Your team already lives in Semrush |
| Ahrefs Brand Radar | $398/mo add-on7 | AI Overviews, ChatGPT, Perplexity, Copilot, Gemini, Grok | You want index-scale prompt data, not just your own list |
| MentionBeat | Free tier; Pro $99/mo — pricing | 6 surfaces incl. Claude, Gemini, Grok — none plan-locked | You need statistical rigor and a fix loop at an SMB price |
| AthenaHQ | Free tier; Starter $295/mo8 | 8 models incl. Claude, Copilot, Grok | You want the widest self-serve model list |
The seven, honestly
1. Peec AI
The closest self-serve equivalent to Profound's core tracking. Peec monitors prompts with visibility, position and sentiment, shows which sources engines lean on, benchmarks competitors, and exports to CSV, Looker Studio and API.3 Self-serve plans (€85/€205/€425 a month) include 50–350 prompts and a choice of 3 models from ChatGPT, AI Mode, AI Overviews, Copilot, Perplexity and Gemini; Claude and others arrive on Enterprise, which stretches to 11 models.3 It states 3,000+ brands and agencies use it.
Choose Peec if you want clean, focused answer-tracking you can buy with a credit card, especially from a European team with European market coverage.
2. Otterly.AI
The price floor of the category: $29/month buys 15 prompts monitored daily across ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Perplexity and Copilot, with share-of-voice, sentiment, citation tracking and GEO URL audits; bigger tiers reach 400 prompts, and Gemini, Claude and AI Mode are paid add-ons.4 It states 30,000+ marketing pros use it, with a 4.8/5 on G2.9 We compare directly in MentionBeat vs Otterly.
Choose Otterly if you're a solo marketer or small team that needs affordable daily monitoring more than statistical depth.
3. Scrunch AI
The enterprise like-for-like. Scrunch monitors ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude, Gemini and Copilot and adds an "Agent Experience Platform" that serves machine-readable versions of your site to AI agents — measurement plus infrastructure, which Profound doesn't sell in that form. Customers named include Lenovo, Skims and Penn State. Pricing isn't published; expect a demo and a sales cycle (checked August 2026).5
Choose Scrunch if you're enterprise-sized anyway and the idea of optimizing your site's agent experience — not just measuring answers — is the capability you're missing.
4. Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit
The already-in-your-stack option. $99/month per domain (billed annually) adds 25 daily-tracked prompts, brand mentions from ChatGPT, Google AI, Gemini and Perplexity, AI visibility reports and an AI-readiness audit to the Semrush suite, with a 7-day trial.6 The cap is real — 25 prompts on one domain is a starting sample, not a program — but the marginal cost and the shared reporting surface are hard to argue with.
Choose Semrush if your team already pays for it and you want AI visibility in the same reports your SEO already lives in.
5. Ahrefs Brand Radar
The different lens. Instead of only running your prompt list, Brand Radar mines a database Ahrefs states at 475M+ monthly prompts across AI Overviews, ChatGPT, Perplexity, Copilot, Gemini and Grok — closer in spirit to Profound's prompt-volume data than anything else on this list — plus YouTube, TikTok and Reddit visibility in beta.7 It's an add-on to Ahrefs plans: $398/month for select platforms, $699/month for all platforms plus 2,500 custom prompt checks.7
Choose Brand Radar if you're an Ahrefs shop and demand-side scale — what the market asks, not just where you stand — is the thing you'd otherwise miss about Profound.
6. MentionBeat
Ours — placed sixth because the list runs from most Profound-like to most different, and we're the opinionated one. MentionBeat measures six surfaces (ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews, Grok) with none locked to a plan — credits are the only limit, from a free tier of 1,500 credits to Pro at $99/month. What we'd point a Profound evaluator at: every headline rate carries a 95% confidence interval, overlapping ranks are marked as ties, results are labelled live, modeled or estimated, and the methodology is public — limitations included. Findings become a fix queue that closes only on a passing re-check, and experiments report lift against baseline, null results too. What we don't have, plainly: prompt-volume data, Copilot or DeepSeek coverage, or log-scale crawler analytics — the free crawler check is a checker, not a log pipeline.
Choose MentionBeat if you need numbers that survive a skeptical meeting and a workflow that proves whether the fixes worked — at a self-serve price. The longer version, trade-offs included, is on why us.
7. AthenaHQ
The widest self-serve model list we verified: ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews, AI Mode, Gemini, Claude, Copilot and Grok, with citation analysis, sentiment, alerts, and GA4/Search Console/Shopify integrations.8 There's a free entry tier; Starter is $295/month (checked August 2026).8
Choose AthenaHQ if broad model coverage without an enterprise contract is your first filter and $295/month fits the budget.
Before comparing seven vendors, get the baseline: MentionBeat's free checker audits any page for AI-answer readiness in about a minute, and the free tier runs a real prompt suite with confidence intervals. No card.
Run the free checkerHow to run the evaluation
- Write your prompt suite first. 20–50 questions your buyers actually ask, in their words. Every tool looks good on its own demo prompts; yours are the test. (How to build a prompt suite.)
- Price the coverage you need, not the sticker. Add up the engines, the add-ons and the billing terms. A $29 sticker with two add-ons and a $99 sticker with everything included can land in the same place.
- Ask the statistics question. How many samples per prompt? Where's the interval? What happens to a rank when two brands overlap? Any vendor on this list — us included — should answer in writing.
- Check the loop. When a tool finds a problem, what happens next — a CSV, or a tracked fix with a re-check? Reading the field is step one; changing it is the job.
- Trial two, not seven. Pick your top two, run the same suite in both for two weeks, and compare not just the rates but what each told you to do — then commit.
And whichever you pick, remember what the tools are for: the comparison pages engines quote still have to be written, the metrics still have to be read honestly, and the loop still has to be run. Full market view in the best GEO tools in 2026.
Frequently asked questions
Three reasons come up most. Engine gating: as of August 2026, Profound's Starter tracks ChatGPT only and Growth tracks three engines, both billed yearly, with the full platform sales-led.1 Fit: its compliance and support model is built for enterprise, which smaller teams pay for without using. And transparency: some buyers want a published methodology and statistical treatment they can audit before purchasing.
Among tools with published pricing, Otterly.AI has the lowest entry at $29/month for 15 prompts (checked August 2026).4 Peec starts at €85/month,3 and MentionBeat and Semrush's AI Visibility Toolkit both start at $99/month. Cheapest depends on coverage: price the engines you actually need, including add-ons, before comparing stickers.
For a first read, yes. MentionBeat's free tier includes 1,500 measurement credits with no card, plus the free checker. AthenaHQ has a free entry tier,8 and HubSpot's AI Search Grader runs a free one-time brand check.10 No free tool replaces ongoing tracking — but they'll tell you whether you have a problem worth paying to track.
Sources & further reading
- Profound — Pricing, checked August 2026.
- Profound — tryprofound.com (capabilities and engine list), checked August 2026.
- Peec AI — Pricing, checked August 2026.
- Otterly.AI — Pricing, checked August 2026.
- Scrunch AI — scrunch.com, checked August 2026.
- Semrush — AI Visibility Toolkit pricing, checked August 2026.
- Ahrefs — Brand Radar, checked August 2026.
- AthenaHQ — athenahq.ai, checked August 2026.
- Otterly.AI — otterly.ai (stated user base and ratings), checked August 2026.
- HubSpot — AI Search Grader, checked August 2026.
- MentionBeat — Pricing and published methodology, current as of August 2026.


